Despite their immense popularity, a dark cloud often hangs over the seemingly upbeat world of Japanese pop idols. They are routinely subjected to inhuman, unrealistic demands on their lives, bodies, eating habits, and relationships, imposed by management, industry, or societal expectations. But a recently concluded court case in Tokyo offered the 4 members of a disbanded idol group a measure of justice and closure.
Origins
SKY GIRLS’ (apostrophe included) was a KPop idol group with an all-Japanese lineup. Korean singer and composer Yang Sungjeung established the group in 2019. It was under the management of SKY Entertainment and ONE TOP Entertainment.
Members Runa, Mirai, Saya, and Karina signed for a 10-year contract in October of that year, at the management office in Tokyo. The group debuted in Korea the following month.
But in July 2020, the members requested contract termination. An attempt at negotiation proved fruitless, and in October, they sent a written request for contract termination by certified mail.
Following the performers’ mass resignation, the management cited now wasted money on an unreleased single and music video, and sued the women for ¥15 million in damages.
The group had barely lasted a year before its demise. So what prompted this sudden resignation?
Abusive Management and Impossible Demands
The pandemic began shortly after SKY GIRLS’ formation. Like so many worldwide regardless of location or occupation, work and life grew challenging for them. But even while working remotely, SKY GIRLS’ troubles had only begun.
Required to report to the management day after day, the performers were subject to intense verbal abuse over video calls. Management reportedly called them “pigs” and harangued them for not losing weight fast enough. They were also constantly yelled at during dance and singing practice sessions.
The result was an increasingly stressful environment which eventually pushed the four women to the breaking point and the demand to terminate their contract so soon after having signed. They were also pressured to undergo plastic surgery. On top of all this, management also withheld their pay.
Despite an attempt at negotiating termination, the two sides were unable to find a mutually agreeable solution. Thus, rightfully impatient and facing very real concerns including their livelihood, the four women requested contract termination by mail and ceased further activity as a group. The management responded in short order with a lawsuit.
The Decision, and a Measure of Closure
Lawyers from Bunkyo, Tokyo-based Rei Law Office represented SKY GIRLS’ former members. A court held that the performers had a right to quit, noting the “strict chain of command” under which they labored. It also batted aside management’s arguments that the four violated their contract by not losing weight. The court said management didn’t give the group enough support to make that contract stipulation realistic.
The organization made the announcement in a press release on 24 July 2021. Rei Law Office is an organization with broad experience including in entertainment law and labor law.
“I remember the fear, and how I was so anxious. I was reminded of how unusual our circumstances were, how abnormal,” one former SKY GIRLS’ member was quoted as saying, following the decision from the Tokyo District Court.
Opinion among the four women as to where to go next has been divided. Saya was quoted as saying “I loved the fans and the other members, and I’d wanted to continue as SKY GIRLS’, so I was disappointed. I’m sad to have had to stop our activities without any notice.”
Meanwhile, member Runa stated “Our parents had great expectations, and we even borrowed money from them, but then we had to quit and things escalated to the point of even a lawsuit! And while I wasn’t able to meet with management in person because of the pandemic, when we did meet with them [over video], it was scary. I felt like the stress was destroying my health.”
But with the lawsuit concluded and the court’s recent decision finding in their favor, the group has a measure of closure. As member Karina put it, “I feel like I’ve been set free.”
What to read next
Idol Yamaguchi Maho Forced to Apologize for Her Own Sexual Assault
Sources
- “KPop Yoningumi Sky Girls’ Keiyaku Kaijo wa yūkō no hanketsu, Aidoru to Geinou Puro ‘Jōshiki to Hijōshiki’ no Kyōkaisen.” Nikkan Gendai Digital, archived at Yahoo News Japan. 1 April 2023, accessed 10 April 2023.
- “Seisei Yōkyū, Sekuhara, Kyūryō Nashi…Zenin de Dattai Shita “K-Pop Gurūpu,” Jimusho kara 1500manen seikyū sare saiban ni.” Bengōshi Dottokomu Nyūsu. 24 July 2021, Accessed 11 April 2023. https://www.bengo4.com/c_18/n_13339/
- “Sky Girls’.” Kpopping.com. Accessed 7 April 2023.
- Sky Girls’ Homepage. Accessed 7 April 2023.
- “SKY GIRLS’ Moto Menbaa Yonin no Soshō Hanketsu ni Tsuite.” Rei Law Office, 28 March 2023, accessed 11 April 2023.
- “SKY GIRLS’ Moto Menbaa Yonin no Soshō ni Tsuite.” Rei Law Office, 24 July 2021, accessed 11 April 2023.
- Tanaka Kyōta. “Aidoru ga ‘Daietto Gimu Hatasazu’ Baishō Motometa Geinō Jimusho ga Haiso.” Asahi Shinbun 29 March 2023. Accessed 7 April 2023.
