[Insider] Japan’s Polls on an Empress Miss an Important Distinction

The Goddess Amaterasu
Princess Aiko is very popular. Many wouldn't mind her becoming Empress. But critics say the polls are misleading. And they're right.

Don’t miss a thing – get our free newsletter

Japan has had eight empresses in its history. (That’s not including Himiko, the legendary shamaness-queen of Yamatai-koku.) The last one was in the Edo period: Go-Sakuramachi held the throne as the country’s 117th Emperor from 1762 until 1771.

Since then, Japan has had only male emperors. And, legally, the lineage can only pass through the male side of the imperial family.

A portrait of Go-Sakuramachi, the eighth woman to assume the title of Empress of Japan.
A portrait of Go-Sakuramachi. (Picture: Wikipedia, By unknown author – http://tenzan.sblo.jp/article/102272649.html, Public Domain)

As I’ve discussed before, that has Japan in something of an imperial panic. Because, currently, there are only two men who can ascend to the throne: Crown Prince Fumihito and his only son, the light novel-loving Prince Hisahito.

That’s stirred up official and public ruminations about what should be done to preserve the imperial line. The obvious answer, of course, is: let women be emperors! If allowed, the first in succession would actually be Aiko, Princess Toshi, the daughter of the current emperor and empress, Emperor Naruhito and Empress Masako.

Aiko, Princess Toshi. (Picture: Wikipedia – By 外務省, CC BY 4.0)

Previous polls have shown that support for Aiko becoming empress is actually high among the Japanese public. Mainichi Shimbun, a prominent left-liberal voice in Japan, reawakened this debate a few days ago when it released a new poll showing that 61% of those asked would support her being the spiritual figurehead of the country. Only 9% said they opposed Aiko in this role.

That seems natural. After all, the imperial line itself is said to descend from a Goddess – Amaterasu Ōkami.

Despite this rich mythology, right-wingers on The Social Media Network Formerly Known as Twitter laid into Mainichi’s poll. The thing is, this time [insert the_worse_guy_you_know.png here], I think they have a point.

The rest of this article is for Insider subscribers only. Already a subscriber? Log in with your account information. Not a subscriber? Join today and we will send you an account registration link. Missing your registration link? Contact us.

Don’t miss a thing – get our free newsletter

Before You Go...

Let’s stay in touch. Get our free newsletter to get a weekly update on our best stories (all human-generated, we promise). You’ll also help keep UJ independent of Google and the social media giants.

Want a preview? Read our archives.

Read our privacy policy