It’s a truism that, if you’re over 30, then no matter where or when you live, you likely think your country is on a slow side into decay and ruin. The younger generation just doesn’t work as hard or show the same respect that your generation did and, really, they should just get off your damn lawn.
People in Japan aren’t immune to this sort of misplaced nostalgia. But a recent interview with a corporate trainer about his “monster new employees” had many in Japan scratching their heads wondering exactly what sort of yesteryear the man was pining for.
The Legal Department Gets Involved
The article from LiveDoor interviews a man named Nobuo (pseudonym), a 38-year-old manager who supervises training for new employees at a Japanese company. All employees at his company undergo two months of training – a long stretch that would test the patience of even the most eager newbie.
One day, during a 15 minute break, four employees mixed-gender went to a convenience store, bought some ice cream, and ate it in the training room during the break. This was, apparently, too much of a break with decorum for Nobuo, who felt he had to say something. “Of course, I don’t mind what people do within their allotted time,” Nobuo said. “But them wanting to eat ice cream took me back.” Maybe he was hoping the employees would eat a more traditional Japanese snack...?
So he gave them a stern warning.
Planning a trip to Japan? Get an authentic, interpreted experience from Unseen Japan Tours and see a side of the country others miss!

"Noah [at Unseen Japan] put together an itinerary that didn’t lock us in and we could travel at our own pace. In Tokyo, he guided us personally on a walking tour. Overall, he made our Japan trip an experience not to forget." - Kate and Simon S., Australia


We hate paywalls. Our content remains both free and fiercely independent. If you love the values we stand for and want to help us expand our coverage of Japan, consider a recurring or one-time donation to the Unseen Japan Journalism Fund today.
しかし、“休憩中におやつって駄目なんですか?”と反抗されてしまう。
「おやつを食べることは構わない、だがアイスは少し違うんじゃないかな? 普通はチョコレートとかじゃないか?」と伝えると、新入社員たちは不満そうな顔をしながらアイスを急いで食べたという。
The employees shot back, “What’s wrong with snacking during break?”
When Nobuo told them, “I don’t mind snacking, but…ice cream? Isn’t chocolate or something more usual?”, they quickly finished the ice cream with scowls on their faces.
But that wasn’t the end of the issue. One or more of the employees apparently filed a confidential complaint with the company’s legal department. Legal staff mildly reprimanded Nobuo and asked him to be more gentle with new employees. “It’ll be a loss to the company if they’re made to quit.”
社内でアイスを食べた新入社員を注意 法務部に密告される事態に – ライブドアニュース
男女4人の新入社員が研修室内で、小休憩で談笑しながらアイスを食べていた。新入社員研修の担当者は「アイスは少し違うんじゃないかな?」と注意。すると注意したことを法務部に「密告」されてしまい、ひと悶着あったという
“I Don’t Get It”
The LiveDoor article has been shared tens of thousands of times on Twitter, where Japanese commenters are having a hard time figuring out what all the fuss is about. In a tweet shared some 40,000 times, user GinNeko quotes the part about Nobuo warning employees about the ice cream and writes, “Huh? Huh? Huh? I don’t understand this sentence.”
x.com
No Description
GinNeko even attached a poll to the thread asking if people thought it was okay for employees to eat ice cream. With over 200,000 respondents, the answer was clear: almost 98% of respondents said, “Who Cares?” (Note: In the vote text below, “NG” is short for the English phrase “No Good” – a common Japanese term for things that are regarded as socially beyond the pale.)

An employee with Sogensha, a publisher based in Tokyo, said, “we not only don’t get warned about eating ice cream – our CEO bakes bread for us to eat. Oh and the other day when I was thinking to myself, ‘This would be great with some honey,’ I noticed there was honey right in front of me.”
桑野崇(書籍編集者) on X (formerly Twitter): “弊社・東京創元社は社内でアイス食べて注意されるどころか、社長が焼いてくれたパンを食べてるからな……。ちなみに昨日のパンもおいしくて、「あ、これにハチミツかけたら完璧に俺好み」と思ったら、目線の先にハチミツがあってですね / X”
弊社・東京創元社は社内でアイス食べて注意されるどころか、社長が焼いてくれたパンを食べてるからな……。ちなみに昨日のパンもおいしくて、「あ、これにハチミツかけたら完璧に俺好み」と思ったら、目線の先にハチミツがあってですね
And the user Childish Teacher argued that there are far better things to admonish employees about:
Childish Teacher on X (formerly Twitter): “社内でアイスを食べた新入社員に注意した上司には『タバコ休憩が良くてアイス休憩がダメな理由』を聞きたいです。タバコよりアイスの方が健康的ですし、周囲への迷惑度もアイスの方が軽いのではないでしょうか。アイスを食べてるくらいで注意するなら、1日に何回もタバコ休憩する人を注意すべきかと。 / X”
社内でアイスを食べた新入社員に注意した上司には『タバコ休憩が良くてアイス休憩がダメな理由』を聞きたいです。タバコよりアイスの方が健康的ですし、周囲への迷惑度もアイスの方が軽いのではないでしょうか。アイスを食べてるくらいで注意するなら、1日に何回もタバコ休憩する人を注意すべきかと。
I want to hear from this manager who warned new employees over ice cream why it’s fine to smoke during break but ice cream is off limits. Ice cream is better for your health than tobacco and causes less trouble for those around you. If you’re going to reprimand people for eating ice cream, you should reprimand people multiple times a day for smoking during their breaks.
From a noise standpoint, ice cream is very low-interference as well. If the employees had been snacking loudly on Baby Star Ramen, for example, I could see cause for annoyance.
In the end, it’s a good thing Nobuo decided to remain anonymous for the article. On the plus side, at least Japanese employees can rest easy knowing that their ice cream habit likely won’t be frowned upon by their colleagues. (Just avoid working wherever Nobuo works.)